Roof Replacement or Repair: What to Do When You’re Ready To Sell

Are you planning to sell your home? If so, you might be focused on curb appeal, fresh paint, and maybe upgrading your landscaping. However, there’s one key feature you may be overlooking that buyers always notice— your roof.

An aging or damaged roof can be a huge red flag for potential buyers. On the flip side, a recently repaired or replaced roof can be a major selling point. So, how do you decide whether to repair or replace your roof before listing your home? Let’s break it down.

1. Start With a Professional Inspection

Before making any decisions, schedule a roof inspection. At HomeWise Roofing & Exteriors, we offer free, honest evaluations to help you understand your roof’s condition.

We’ll assess:

  • Shingle wear and granule loss
  • Structural integrity
  • Flashing and ventilation
  • Signs of leaks or previous water damage

This inspection provides a solid foundation for your next steps and gives you documentation to share with buyers or realtors.

2. Minor Issues? Repairs May Be Enough

If your roof is generally in good condition and only has a few missing or damaged shingles, simple repairs might be all you need. These types of fixes are cost-effective and still show potential buyers that the home has been maintained.

Small repairs may include:

  • Replacing a few shingles
  • Resealing flashing
  • Cleaning up debris or moss

Be sure to keep records of all repairs to provide to buyers during negotiations.

3. Major Problems? Consider Full Replacement

If your roof is over 20 years old, has widespread damage, or has been patched multiple times, a full replacement may be the smarter move. While the upfront cost is higher, it can help you:

  • Sell faster
  • Justify a higher asking price
  • Avoid negotiating repairs with buyers
  • Prevent last-minute deal breakers after inspection

A new roof is a major asset in your home’s listing and can significantly increase buyer confidence.

4. Work With Your Real Estate Agent

Talk to your realtor about your roof’s condition and how it might affect your listing strategy. They can help you weigh the costs of replacement versus repair and how that choice might impact your home’s time on the market or final sale price.

In competitive markets like Omaha, buyers are less likely to want a “project” home—and a new roof signals move-in-ready quality.

5. Choose Materials That Add Value

If you do replace your roof, consider using materials that align with your neighborhood and offer long-term benefits. Architectural shingles or Class 4 impact-resistant products are attractive to buyers and may qualify them for home insurance discounts.

At HomeWise Roofing & Exteriors, we help sellers choose smart, appealing roofing options that support both value and longevity.

ROI: Is It Worth It?

According to industry estimates, a new roof can offer an ROI of 60–70%, depending on the local market. Beyond the numbers, a well-maintained or brand-new roof can keep your home from sitting unsold—or losing value during negotiations.

Selling Soon? Let’s Make Sure Your Roof Isn’t Holding You Back

At HomeWise Roofing & Exteriors, we specialize in helping homeowners make smart, cost-effective decisions before selling. Whether it’s a simple repair or a full roof replacement, our team provides honest recommendations tailored to your goals.

Getting ready to sell? Start with a free roof inspection from HomeWise Roofing & Exteriors. We’ll help you make the best choice to boost your home’s value—and your peace of mind.

Share this post

Schedule a Consultation

Request an Estimate

Your Information